Perhaps one of the contributions of phygital ministry, as we’ve come to understand it through the Phygital Fellows and the Phygital Gathering, is a coming back to soul. We’ve watched remarkable practitioners of soulful engagement, soulful creation, and soulful content, and that practice kept raising a harder question underneath it: how are these technologies forming our souls in the first place? We share common questions about how scrolling, the attention economy, and ubiquitous messaging are shaping us, and shaping the people we minister to.
From there, the conversation turned toward making, not just noticing. What makes digital work soul-inspiring and community-forming? How does the digital world still hold grace and space for the spirit?
During our Fellowship, we spent time with Dr. Filipe Maia, who framed his wisdom through Simone Weil’s Reflections on the Right Use of School Studies with a View to the Love of God. Dr. Maia kept returning to a single question: what is receiving our attention, and what is worthy of it? Drawing on Weil, he named prayer as a collective counter-practice against the attention economy, and wondered aloud about something like an attention boycott.
What’s emerging for us is neither of the easy answers. It isn’t baptizing technology as the vehicle for our spiritual attention, and it isn’t withdrawing from it for the sake of our spiritual health either. We can ask the digital space to help with our formation, but because we’re interacting with these tools, we also need to be formed outside of them. That’s not the same as staying away from them. The real question becomes: what formation are we already bringing into the room? What kind of people do we need to already be, regardless of how we engage these tools?
Rev. Emily McGinley, a pastor in San Francisco, names what is at stake in the formation we bring:
“Humans are deeply messy, imperfect, inconsistent, and frail – both physically and spiritually. Technology and transhumanism [promise] to rid us of the very thing that makes Christianity so distinct, frustrating, and wonder-filled. That God would find our flesh fit to make a home in is not only confounding to our ‘earthly’ sensibilities but profoundly moving and affirming of our worthiness.”
We were given a vivid picture of this worthiness and groundedness at the Phygital Gathering, in a conversation between a senior creative from an innovative movie studio and a premier psychologist. What became clear was that imagination alone wasn’t enough. Being grounded was what was actually needed. Creativity by itself couldn’t have carried those large-scale films into being; it took a groundedness underneath the creativity, a formation the work flowed out of, not the other way around.
That groundedness is also what makes this soulful work collective rather than solitary. It’s one human who has done some work meeting another human who has done some work, and the two of them walking the road together. That takes emotional intelligence. It also means rethinking what actually matters in the first place.
The only way to deal with the attention economy is to be a strong person outside of it, so that we are not trapped by it. It is an immunity that is spiritual, and it is built the way Dr. Maia suggested, in practices we share, like prayer. That doesn’t mean staying away from the tools. It means taking deeply formed lives into the phygital space.
If the phygital space is going to hold grace and space for the spirit, it will be because the people entering it have first been formed somewhere else. Perhaps that is the real work of phygital ministry: not only learning to enter these spaces, but learning to come back to soul, again and again, so that what we bring into them is worth receiving. As Rev. McGinley reminds us, the response “ought not be dread or despair but a question of how we might faithfully help technology live into its vocation.”
From Rev. Emily McGinley
1) This is accompanied with a sense of dread, anxiety, and existential despair. At the center of this is a deep sense of the absence of God or, more to the point, that there is a power greater than God that will snuff out the human spirit, rendering actual humans obselete or, even worse, problematic to a much more preferable future. At the heart of this, I think, they struggle internally – not only with the Christian insistence that “Jesus is Lord” in the face of all that would say he is definitely not, but also with the ancient anxiety of sin, imperfection, and the inherent embarrassment of human-ness that comes with the “enfleshed” experience. Humans are deeply messy, imperfect, inconsistent, and frail – both physically and spiritually. Technology and transhumanism promises to rid us of the very thing that makes Christianity so distinct, frustrating, and wonder-filled. That God would find our flesh fit to make a home in is not only confounding to our “earthly” sensibilities but profoundly moving and affirming of our worthiness. “The Word became flesh and blood, and moved into the neighborhood,” as Eugene Peterson put it, and we are made utterly speechless as we are liberated to proudly fill our flesh in the face of a world that would pour shame on that very truth.
2) Scripture tells us – in ways both plain and obliquely – that all of creation is imbued with a purpose. This vocational identity extends even to the things that people create. How we use them, the trade offs we make in order to use them, are part of the calculation of our vocational purpose. But not only that, as co-creators with God, part of our responsibility is to assist (as God does for us) in helping other aspects of creation fulfill their vocation – whether it is money, tools, or technologies. Like most new technology, things like AI can seem “magical” but if we recall that nothing is beyond the authority of God’s activity and power then the response ought not be dread or despair but a question of how we might faithfully help technology live into its vocation – which is a different question than how can we develop it as fast as possible and without regard to its impact on vulnerable communities, cognitive rigor, or our surrounding ecology.
Formation Outside the Digital Space, For the Sake of the Digital Space
Perhaps one of the contributions of phygital ministry, as we’ve come to understand it through the Phygital Fellows and the Phygital Gathering, is a coming back to soul. We’ve watched remarkable practitioners of soulful engagement, soulful creation, and soulful content, and that practice kept raising a harder question underneath it: how are these technologies forming our souls in the first place? We share common questions about how scrolling, the attention economy, and ubiquitous messaging are shaping us, and shaping the people we minister to.
From there the conversation turned toward making, not just noticing. What makes digital work soul-inspiring and community-forming? How does the digital world still hold grace and space for the spirit?
During our Fellowship, we spent time with Dr. Filipe Maia, who framed his wisdom through Simone Weil’s Reflections on the Right Use of School Studies with a View to the Love of God. Dr. Maia kept returning to a single question: what is receiving our attention, and what is worthy of it? Drawing on Weil, he named prayer as a collective counter-practice against the attention economy, and wondered aloud about something like an attention boycott.
What’s emerging for us is neither of the easy answers. It isn’t baptizing technology as the vehicle for our spiritual attention, and it isn’t withdrawing from it for the sake of our spiritual health either. We can ask the digital space to help with our formation, but because we’re interacting with these tools, we also need to be formed outside of them. That’s not the same as staying away from them. The real question becomes: what formation are we already bringing into the room? What kind of person do I need to already be, regardless of how I engage these tools?
We were given a vivid picture of this at the Phygital Gathering, in a conversation between a senior creative from an innovative movie studio and a premier psychologist. What became clear was that imagination alone wasn’t enough. Being grounded was what was actually needed. Creativity by itself couldn’t have carried those large-scale films into being; it took a groundedness underneath the creativity, a formation the work flowed out of, not the other way around.
That groundedness is also what makes this soulful work collective rather than solitary. It’s one human who has done some work meeting another human who has done some work, and the two of them walking the road together. That takes emotional intelligence. It also means rethinking what actually matters in the first place.
Because these tools pull and manipulate us, often without our knowing, we need to be formed outside of them. That does not mean staying away from the digital tools. It means taking deeply formed lives into the phygital space. The only way to deal with the attention economy is to be a strong person outside of it, so that we are not trapped by it. It is an immunity that is spiritual. Prayer, as a collective counter-practice, is one way that immunity is built, and being imaginative alone is not enough. It takes being grounded.
If the phygital space is going to hold grace and space for the spirit, it will be because the people entering it have first been formed somewhere else. Perhaps that is the real work of phygital ministry: not only learning to enter these spaces, but learning to come back to soul, again and again, so that what we bring into them is worth receiving.



